TheRealDealbyLucyMonroe

by Candy Monday, February 07, 2005 at 07:38 AM
Our Grade:
D-
Title: The Real Deal
Author: Lucy Monroe
Publication Info: Brava (an imprint of Kensington) 2004, ISBN: 075820860X
Genre: Contemporary Romance

By all rights I should’ve loved The Real Deal. It has a computer geek hero. It has a heroine who has body image and self-esteem issues. It’s about two oddballs who have never felt like they belonged finding love and acceptance with each other. It has hot love scenes. And it has received rave reviews from just about everybody.

Yeah, but you know what? It stinks. I had an inkling that this was going to be a rough ride when right in the beginning of the book, the katana the hero uses while practicing swordplay (he’s a computer geek, so of course he has to practice martial arts instead of running the treadmill to keep the geeky flabbiness at bay, right? Riiiiight) is referred to as a Korean sword. The problem is, the katana isn’t Korean, it’s Japanese, and geeks know this. Confusing a katana as being Korean would be like confusing Windows with MacOS. The Koreans have their own swords, none of them referred to as “katana” (which makes sense because katana is a Japanese word). So right off the bat Simon Brant’s credibility as a geeky hunka hunka burnin’ love is shattered.

But that’s petty nitpicking, really. If this were the biggest irritation in the book, I would’ve handled it fine because God knows I’ve enjoyed books that have made big blunders. But the The Real Deal was excruciating to read on all levels. The writing style veered from hilariously purple to hilariously wooden, the characters were poorly-recycled archetypes at best, and the plot was completely humdrum when it wasn’t busy being implausible.

More,more,more!>
Picture of {name}
6 comments Bookmark to del.icio.us Add to Technorati favorites Digg this post on digg.com RSS
Categories: Reviews by Author, L-PReviews by Grade: D

Tags: This entry has not been tagged yet.

Comments

Picture of Jac Jac said on...
06.15.05 at 09:15 PM |

Thanks for the honest review of this book.  Finally.  Someone who tells it like it is.  It was getting a bit tiresome listening to everyone kiss-ass (can I say that here?!) to the author about her ‘oh-so-fantastic’ book when it really truly sucks. 

Yes, I did attempt to read it but sadly couldn’t make it very far without wanting to rip it to shreds. 

Tripe.  That’s all it is from start to finish.  Utter tripe!

And I think you hit the nail on the head - RE: the prudish tone v.s. sex.

Picture of Candy Candy said on...
06.15.05 at 09:49 PM |

Whoa! Someone else who didn’t like The Real Deal comes out of the closet!

Now, where are the rest of you? Come out, come out, wherever you are....

Oh, and of course you can say kiss-ass. You can also say a lot worse here. Please refer to our official The Official Smart Bitch Policy on Acceptable Language.

Picture of Stacie Stacie said on...
09.08.05 at 07:05 AM |

I read this book yesterday and was glad I didn’t waste money on the trade-size version.  I read a couple reviews from other sites (that I thought I trusted) but yours was the only one that spoke the truth.  This book really sucked. I could barely finish it and wanted to smack my head several times at the purple prose and cliched characters.

Thanks for the honest review. ~Stacie

Picture of Michelle Michelle said on...
04.04.06 at 11:41 PM |

THANK YOU. I thought I was the only one who hated this book. I don’t know why all the other review sites praised it. It seemed like I was rolling my eyes every other page - I didn’t even bother to finish the book for fear of doing permanent damage to my eyes. What a waste of my time and money.

Picture of ShuzLuva ShuzLuva said on...
05.31.06 at 11:49 AM |

OMG! I thought it was just me! I read all of these fabulous reviews about this book - that this is the best book Monroe has written (never mind it was the first) and it was HAWT.

Well, hawt is not the word I’d use for this tripe. I was either bored or frustrated by the characters and felt that the writing was painfully bad. I knew that something was weird about the sex scenes - weird in that Monroe did dance around using words like vagina, penis, suck, fuck or anything else that didn’t sound like it had been run past a censor first - and yet the scenes were supposed to be quite graphic. Harumph.

Thank you, Candy. I feel so much better now. I guess I needed my lowly opinion justified by someone I respect!

Picture of Ssmithford Ssmithford said on...
09.20.07 at 03:29 AM |

This book has me in mind of a romance I suffered through.  All the signs were there from the blurb on the back to the teaser inside: Vampire book.  I was hot, I was ready...I was completely surprised by the hero revealing he was a 3000 year old SPACE ALIEN (!!!!!) right before a major (and the first!) sex scene in the book.  If it weren’t for the fact that the ONLY thing the author got right was the sex than I’d have incinerated the damn thing on the spot.

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: