TheDemon’sDaughterByEmmaHolly

by Candy Wednesday, July 27, 2005 at 03:52 PM
Our Grade:
B
Title: The Demon's Daughter
Author: Emma Holly
Publication Info: Berkley Publishing Group 2004, ISBN: 0425199185
Genre: Paranormal

OK, all of you who were taking bets on whether I’d love or hate The Demon’s Daughter can now close the books because the results are in: I liked. Liked it quite a bit, actually, but certain issues with the storytelling prevent me from giving it an outright A, though it’s still a keeper.

This is the first romantic steampunk novel I’ve ever read. The world is somewhat similar to Victorian England, in that there is a queen named Victoria and certain aspects of the culture distinctly resemble that of late nineteenth-century England, but there the resemblance ends. Like many SF/F novels, geography is compressed; on the same relatively small continental mass are countries that are analogues to real-world Mediterranean, African, Caribbean, Indian and Middle-Eastern cultures.

And then there are the Yama, humanoid beings in the coldest reaches of the far north. The humans call them demons, though not to their faces. The discovery of their advanced civilization is a relatively recent one when the book starts. The humans and non-humans are just barely beginning to learn to co-exist. One of the treaties struck up between Queen Victoria and the Yamish Emperor involves exiling the criminal lower-class demons (known as rohn) into the dockside districts of Avvar (think late nineteenth-century London with more diversity and fewer racial hang-ups). In exchange, the demons export their advanced technologies, such as electric horseless carriages, gasless lights and advanced surgical techniques.

More,more,more!>
Picture of {name}
12 commentsTrackback Bookmark to del.icio.us Add to Technorati favorites Digg this post on digg.com RSS
Categories: Reviews by Author, H-KReviews by Grade: B

Tags: This entry has not been tagged yet.

Comments

Picture of AngieW AngieW said on...
07.27.05 at 04:51 PM |

I don’t have anything to add to about this book but I think it’s funny that you called Sarah an ignorant slut since that has become quite the term of affection on an author’s loop after the creation of the Dear Charlie and Angie letters. It made me laugh out loud (yes LOL) when I saw it.

Picture of Robin Robin said on...
07.27.05 at 04:56 PM |

I KNEW you were going to like this book.  In addition to that odiously heinous camel toe scene (which honest to whatever god you prefer made me put down the book for a minute to recover), I also had to get past the ridiculously hasty sexathons.  I actually liked this book better the second time I read it—for whatever reasons, my annoyance with certain elements lessened.  My biggest complaint was that I wanted Holly to massage the steampunk details more for me so that I could savor her genius a bit more.  But really, her past few Romances have seemed rushed and a little more superficial to me, so maybe she’s being pressured by her publisher to get books out faster?

Picture of Maili Maili said on...
07.27.05 at 05:50 PM |

Holy fuck! I liked it but I honestly didn’t think you’d go for it. Yay. :D It has a B out of me, IIRC. I’m curious about Charles, too. Let’s hope EH will return to that world some day. And hope that more authors will give this lark a good try, too.

Picture of notyourtypicalsouthernbelle notyourtypicalsouthernbelle said on...
07.27.05 at 06:06 PM |

Sounds like a pretty good read.  I’ll have to see if I can find it somewhere.

Picture of Meljean Meljean said on...
07.27.05 at 06:17 PM |

I liked it a lot, too—had much the same reaction.

Picture of Robin Robin said on...
07.27.05 at 07:38 PM |

“I’m curious about Charles, too. Let’s hope EH will return to that world some day.”

I just checked her website, and she has a Demon story in the anthology “Hot Spell,” to be released in November (and also featuring Meljean’s story!).  Supposedly it’s to be read as a sequel of some sort to TDD. I’m hoping she writes Charles and Beth’s story—the setup is definitely there at the end of TDD.

Her new “Midnight” book is being published in October, and I can’t wait, because it’s Lucius’ story. I adored Catching Midnight, but wasn’t as impressed with the next two installments, so I’m hoping this one will be wonderful, since Lucius is the most interesting character in the series to me.

I have to say that I love Holly’s website because she provides long excerpts of her work there.  I’ve become more and more in the habit of reading excerpted sections of books before buying them, at least with authors who are unfamiliar or uneven.

Picture of Candy Candy said on...
07.27.05 at 10:05 PM |

Angie: (...) I think it’s funny that you called Sarah an ignorant slut since that has become quite the term of affection (...)

Yeah, I was basically parodying that SNL Weekend Update bit that Dan Aykroyd did. Plus any chance to call Sarah a slut is golden.

Robin: I KNEW you were going to like this book.

I’ve figured out that if Meljean and you like the book, odds are pretty damn high that I’ll like it too.

I just checked her website, and she has a Demon story in the anthology “Hot Spell,” to be released in November (and also featuring Meljean’s story!).

*makes puppy eyes at Meljean in hopes of getting an advance copy*

*feels vaguely ashamed for being an advance copy slut*

*gets over feelings of vague shame and resumes puppy eyes*

Picture of Sarah Sarah said on...
07.28.05 at 06:51 AM |

her propensity for mathematics (hey, is she part Chinese too?)

BWAHAHAHAH!

Candy and I emailed back and forth in erudite fashion over Adrian, and my position still hasn’t changed. I found him inconsistent and somewhat hypocritical, though I can see Candy’s point and certainly the book might have turned around for me if I’d continued reading.

But I do get a sense of pleasure that she and I reacted so differently to this book, since it definitely gives the readers of this here website a sense of what each of us prefer.

To sum up:

Cassie Edwards:
Sarah- BOO!
Candy- BOO!

The Demon’s Daughter:
Candy- YAY!
Sarah- BOO!

Bet Me:
Candy-YAY!
Sarah-YAY!

Picture of fiveandfour fiveandfour said on...
07.28.05 at 08:19 AM |

My biggest reservations with the book had to do with the overall tone and the erotic elements.

I guess the things you had reservations about, but could forgive (if that’s the right word) were the things I had reservations about, but couldn’t get over.  These things plus my annoyance at Adrian, my moderate liking of Roxanne, and my never *quite* getting fully into the world EH was going for all added up to my ho-hum thoughts on this story.

And yes, the daimyo thing got me every time: it threw me out of the story each time I came across that word because it seemed so out of place.  If deliberate, I wonder at the logic behind her choice at that word.

Picture of Candy Candy said on...
07.28.05 at 02:02 PM |

I guess the things you had reservations about, but could forgive (if that’s the right word) were the things I had reservations about, but couldn’t get over.

Oh yeah, I think the reasons why we like or dislike books basically boil down to that same reaction. Sarah found the heroine for Tell Me Lies unforgivably stupid, whereas I thought she was a bit of a dipshit but still likeable. Most people looooove Linda Howard’s alpha heroes, whereas I tend to think they’re grade-A assholes who need to be beaten soundly on the head. It’s all in our tolerance levels and how we interpret certain actions.

I’d love to know whether Holly realized that daimyo was Japanese word before she used it, too.

Picture of Maili Maili said on...
07.28.05 at 05:36 PM |

Something has just occurred to me: have you read Susan Squires’s BODY ELECTRIC? Do give it a try if you haven’t yet.

Picture of Robin Robin said on...
07.28.05 at 09:10 PM |

“Most people looooove Linda Howard’s alpha heroes, whereas I tend to think they’re grade-A assholes who need to be beaten soundly on the head.”

A kick to the balls might be good, too.

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: