




by SB Sarah • Wednesday, January 23, 2008 at 11:05 AM
An awesome librarian (is there another kind?) forwarded me a link to this article from the Reference & User Services Quarterly (THAT IS THE SEXIEST NAME OVER OMG *PANT*) article from “The Alert Collector,” which offers five librarians’ suggestions on building a romance genre collection: Core Collections in Genre Studies: Romance Fiction 101. (Also, the sexiest title ever, and thank you Mr.MS. Wyatt (my apologies) for not writing something that referenced heaving bodices or man-titty).
From the article:
The RUSA Collection Development and Evaluation Section (CODES) voted to create a new juried list highlighting the best in genre literature. The Reading List, as the new list will be called, honors the single best title in eight genre categories: romance, mystery, science fiction, fantasy, horror, historical fiction, women’s fiction, and the adrenaline genre group consisting of thriller, suspense, and adventure.
I will start composing sonnets to the awesomeness of this decision in a moment, but first, I want to say, HELL YES and FUCK YEAH. I personally loved the genre fiction section - which totaled three shelves - at the library at my college, and only allowed myself to take one book per week, even if I finished it in one night. Otherwise, I’d get no other reading accomplished.
So to the RUSA, with your sexy, sassy name: MMMMMMWAH. Great idea. And to accomplish this task, they gathered five librarians to profile a subgenre of romance: contemporary, historical, suspense, paranormal, and Regency.
And to Ms. Wyatt (I think you wrote this part) I’d like to nominate you for the I-Just-Invented-It Award for Asskickingly Non-Condescending Description of Romance and buy you the beverage of your choice:
Romance novels are built around the relationship between hero and heroine and the conflicts within that relationship. They are ultimately positive and optimistic novels that involve the reader on an emotional level. Fans of this genre love the snappy dialogue, well-crafted scenes, connection between the characters, and details of the character’s lifestyles.
WORD UP TO YOU MA’AM. One note though to Dudesse of Excellence. Ms. Wyatt: You list some great web sites as references, but what about us and Dear Author?! DUDE! Epic fail!
Now, minor hissyfit notwithstanding, let us moving on. Here are the selections recommended for building a balanced romance novel bookshelf representing each of the aforementioned subgenres - with my commentary and assorted linkage.
Kristin Ramsdell, of the California State University East Bay library and winner of the 1996 RWA Librarian of the Year award, recommended the following Regencies:
A Garden Folly
by Candice Hern
Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand
by Carla Kelly
The Rake’s Rainbow
by Allison Lane
A Debt to Delia
by Barbara Metzger
Lady Alex’s Gamble
by Evelyn Richardson
As Ramsdell notes in her introduction, all of these Regencies are out of print - so, what Regency romances that are still in print would you recommend for the essential genre- representative library bookshelf?
Georgine Olson, who works at the North Star Borough Public Library in Fairbanks, Alaska, recommended the following historical romances:
Forbidden Magic
by Jo Beverley
The Wild Child
by Mary Jo Putney
The Lightkeeper
by Susan Wiggs
The Duke And I
by Julia Quinn (SB Sarah notes - I’ve mentioned before that this book is among my very favorite historical romances, bar none).
Scandalous Lovers
by Robin Schone (I thought Schone was considered erotica?)
What would you add to an historical romance Must Have shelf?
Neal Wyatt, editor of the Alert Collector, recommends the following contemporary romances:
Bet Me
by Jennifer Crusie (Yes, yes, a thousand times, yes. Is it fair to call a contemporary romance “Seminal?” All references to man pudding aside, this is one of the best I’ve read.)
See Jane Score
by Rachel Gibson
Blame It On Cupid
by Jennifer Greene
Natural Born Charmer
by Susan Elizabeth Phillips (featuring SEP’s new signature headless dancing woman cover - woot!)
Born in Fire
by Nora Roberts (I could not wish a worse challenge on a librarian than picking one Roberts novel to recommend as representative of contemporary romance. But I do like this one (and I like Born in Ice even better because it features a strong independent heroine excelling at traditional domestic responsibilities as an innkeeper).
Obvious question alert - what others would you recommend?
Retired librarian Joyce Saricks won the 2000 RWA Librarian of the Year award, and recommended the following romantic suspense novels:
The Unsung Hero
by Suzanne Brockmann (Which is also the very first book I reviewed for SBTB back in January 2005.)
Chill Factor
by Sandra Brown
Heartbreaker
by Julie Garwood
Always Time to Die
by Elizabeth Lowell (I am so amused to see Garwood and Lowell in suspense instead of historical, which is the subgenre I associate them with)
My Brother Michael
by Mary Stewart
Hey! What about ...?
Lynne Welch works at the Herrick Memorial Library in Wellington, Ohio, and was the 2004 RWA Librarian of the Year. She writes, “[p]aranormal is the umbrella under which speculative fiction merges with romance, both as integral to the plot as is the HEA” (124) (Word. Up.) She recommends the following novels for a paranormal romance collection:
Dark Prince (The Carpathians Series, Book 1)
by Christine Feehan (I loved this one, especially because of the heroine, but ultimately I thought the series became formulaic)
White Lies
by Jayne Ann Krentz
Heart Mate
by Robin D. Owens
Gabriel’s Ghost
by Linnea Sinclair
Cinderman
by Anne Stuart (Though out of print, the description provided by Welch cracks me up: “they join forces...[as] they master their new superpowers.” I got to get me a copy!)
What would you add? This will turn into the biggest, most diverse GS vs. STA column ever, but I’m very curious what you’d put on the “Romance 101” shelf at a library, given the budget and discerning taste to assemble it.





Page 1 of 1 pages